Chlorinated vs Non Chlorinated Brake Cleaners Comparison
Comparing chlorinated and non-chlorinated brake cleaners is important because they have different compositions and properties that can impact their effectiveness. Here is our comparison to help you make the right decision.
What are Chlorinated Brake Cleaners?
Chlorinated brake cleaners are a type of brake cleaner that contains chlorinated solvents, such as methylene chloride or 1,1,1-trichloroethane, as the active cleaning ingredient. These solvents are effective at quickly dissolving and removing grease, oil, brake fluid, and other contaminants from brake components.
Chlorinated brake cleaners are known for their strong cleaning power and ability to penetrate and break down tough residues. They are often used in automotive and industrial settings for cleaning brake drums, rotors, calipers, and other brake parts.
However, chlorinated brake cleaners have several drawbacks. They are considered hazardous to health due to the potential for exposure to chlorinated solvents, which are known to be carcinogenic and can cause other health issues with prolonged or repeated exposure.
Additionally, chlorinated brake cleaners can be harmful to the environment, as chlorinated solvents are persistent in the environment and can contribute to ozone depletion.
Due to these health and environmental concerns, many regions have regulations restricting or banning the use of chlorinated solvents in brake cleaners. As a result, non-chlorinated brake cleaners have become more popular as a safer alternative.
What are Non-Chlorinated Brake Cleaners?
Non-chlorinated brake cleaners are a type of brake cleaners that do not contain chlorinated solvents, such as methylene chloride or 1,1,1-trichloroethane, which are common in chlorinated brake cleaners. Instead, non-chlorinated brake cleaners use alternative solvents, such as acetone, isopropanol, or ethyl acetate, as the active cleaning ingredients.
Non-chlorinated brake cleaners are known for their effectiveness in quickly dissolving and removing grease, oil, brake fluid, and other contaminants from brake components. They are widely used in automotive and industrial settings for cleaning brake drums, rotors, calipers, and other brake parts.
One of the main advantages of non-chlorinated brake cleaners is their improved safety profile compared to chlorinated brake cleaners. Non-chlorinated cleaners are less toxic and less harmful to the environment. They also have a milder odor, which can be more pleasant for users.
However, non-chlorinated brake cleaners may not be as effective at cutting through tough residues as chlorinated cleaners. They may also be more flammable than chlorinated cleaners, so proper precautions should be taken when using them.
Overall, non-chlorinated brake cleaners are a safer alternative to chlorinated cleaners, with similar cleaning effectiveness for most applications. They are often preferred in regions where the use of chlorinated solvents is regulated or banned due to health and environmental concerns.
Chlorinated vs Non Chlorinated Brake Cleaners
Here is a detailed comparison between the two.
Composition
Chlorinated Brake Cleaners contain chlorinated solvents, such as methylene chloride or 1,1,1-trichloroethane, as the active cleaning ingredient.
Non-Chlorinated Brake Cleaners use alternative solvents, such as acetone, isopropanol, or ethyl acetate, as the active cleaning ingredients, and do not contain chlorinated solvents.
Effectiveness
Chlorinated Brake Cleaners are known for their strong cleaning power and ability to quickly dissolve and remove tough contaminants, such as grease and oil, from brake components.
Non-Chlorinated Brake Cleaners are also effective at cleaning brake components but may not be as aggressive at removing certain types of contaminants as chlorinated cleaners.
Safety
Chlorinated Brake Cleanes pose health risks due to the potential for exposure to chlorinated solvents, which are carcinogenic and can cause other health issues.
Non-Chlorinated Brake Cleaners are considered safer for users and the environment, as they do not contain chlorinated solvents and are less toxic.
Environmental Impact
Chlorinated Brake Cleaners can contribute to ozone depletion and groundwater contamination if not disposed of properly.
Non-Chlorinated Brake Cleaners are less harmful to the environment, as they do not contain chlorinated solvents.
Regulatory Compliance
Chlorinated Brake Cleaners in many regions, the use of chlorinated solvents in brake cleaners is regulated or banned due to health and environmental concerns.
Non-Chlorinated Brake Cleaners are often preferred in areas where the use of chlorinated solvents is restricted to comply with regulations.
Odor
Chlorinated Brake Cleaners tend to have a strong, chemical-like odor.
Non-Chlorinated Brake Cleaners may have a milder odor, which can be more pleasant for users.
Flammability
Chlorinated Brake Cleaners are typically less flammable than non-chlorinated cleaners.
Non-Chlorinated Brake Cleaners may be more flammable, so proper precautions should be taken when using them.
Which is Better; Chlorinated or Non Chlorinated Brake Cleaners?
In choosing between chlorinated and non-chlorinated brake cleaners, prioritize safety and environmental impact. Non-chlorinated cleaners are generally safer for users and the environment due to the absence of chlorinated solvents, which are known to be harmful. They may have a milder odor and are less likely to contribute to ozone depletion or groundwater contamination.
However, if you require a cleaner with strong cleaning power for tough contaminants, chlorinated cleaners may be more effective. In this case, use them in a well-ventilated area and with proper safety precautions to minimize risks.
Overall, non-chlorinated brake cleaners are often the better choice, especially considering regulatory compliance and long-term health and environmental impacts. If the cleaning task does not require the extra strength of chlorinated cleaners, opt for the safer and more environmentally friendly non-chlorinated alternatives.
You May Also Like
I’m Alex, a seasoned mechanical teacher with over 20 years of hands-on experience in Australia. My passion for all things automotive has driven me to establish this blog, aiming to share my wealth of knowledge and expertise with fellow enthusiasts, DIYers, and anyone keen on understanding the mechanics behind the machines we rely on daily.
